ASST0: Introduction to OS/161
This assignment is available online at
This assignment introduces you to the OS/161 source code and toolchain that you will use throughout the rest of the assignments.
It is unlikely that you have used OS/161 before, but some of the other tools may be familiar to you:
OS/161 includes both
the sources of the the operating system you will be designing, implementing, running and debugging, and
a toolchain for cross compiling and running your kernel, including a machine simulator called
Git: a distributed source control tool that tracks your changes to OS/161 and enables effective collaboration.
GDB: the GNU debugger which allows you to control and inspect your running system.
After completing ASST0 you should:
Have set up your OS/161 development environment.
Understand the source code structure of OS/161.
Be comfortable navigating the OS/161 sources to determine where and how things are done.
Have been introduced to Git and GDB.
Be able to, modify, build and run your first OS/161 kernel.
1.2. A Note on Cut-and-Paste
Another assignment objective is to get you working efficiently in a Linux development environment using standard command-line development tools. Unlike many of the things you will find online ASST0 is not a tutorial. You will go slower, but you will learn a lot more from figuring out how to: "Run the first OS/161 thread test and then shut down your kernel" than how to:
trinity@zion:~$ sys161 kernel "tt1;q"
Following these kinds of written instructions will also better prepare you to interact with other OS/161 hackers in person and in the online forum.
1.3. A Note on Learning Git
Another objective of this course is to help you learn to use common development tools, particularly Git. However, like most programming tools the best way to learn Git is through the extensive online documentation and multiple good online tutorials ( 1, 2, etc.).
As a result, we have removed Git coverage from this introduction. Any documentation we could provide is unlikely to be complete and up-to-date, and this will also provide you with good practice in online learning. Feel free to ask your course staff or other students for help, either in person or using the forum. Chances are many of them use Git on a daily basis.
Like anything else, learning Git takes practice, more practice, and patience. But here’s one tip: read the output generated by Git commands. Git produces remarkably useful output, particularly when an error occurs or when it didn’t accomplished what you wanted. Frequently the output tells you exactly what to do to fix the problem—down to the commands that you should type.
1.4. Collaboration Guidelines
ASST0 focuses on getting your environment set up and familiarizing you with the source code you will be modifying. There is a small amount of coding involved, but not too much. Here are guidelines for how to work with your partner—if you have one—and with other students:
|Working side-by-side with your partner is strongly encouraged.|
Helping other students set up their
|Helping each other with Git is encouraged.|
|Discussing the code reading questions and browsing the source code with other students is encouraged.|
|Dividing the code reading questions and development tasks between partners is discouraged.|
|Copying any answers from anyone who is not your partner or anywhere else and submitting them as your own is cheating.|
|You may not refer to or incorporate any external sources without explicit permission 2.|
2. Choosing and Initializing Your Development Environment
Developing for OS/161 requires specialized tools. These comprise the
test161 testing framework, the
sys161 system simulator,
and cross-compilers to create
Instructions for obtaining the OS/161 toolchain and source code are available on the setup page. Please follow those instructions carefully and return when have the toolchain set up. We’ll download the sources below.
3. Configuring, Building, and Running a Kernel
Now that you have your development environment ready, on to the fun stuff: building and booting your first OS/161 kernel.
3.1. Download the OS/161 Source Code
We distribute the
ops-class.org OS/161 source code using Git. Starting with a clone of our repository makes it easy for us to distribute updates, which can be merged easily into your repository.
First, choose a directory to work in:
If you are using our Vagrant virtual machine, you can run Git either inside or outside of your virtual machine, assuming your host machine has Git installed. For simplicity, we suggest cloning the sources inside your virtual machine in
/home/trinity/src, which should be an empty directory.
If you have the toolchain installed natively you can create your source directory wherever you want.
Let’s say you’ve chosen a directory called
src, which should either not exist or (in the case of the Vagrant VM) be
ops-class.org Git repository. into that directory.
Note that we refer to this directory as your source directory. In contrast, your root directory is where your built kernel
and other binaries are installed and where you run
3.2. Configure Your OS/161 Source Tree
The next step is to configure the OS/161 sources by running the
configure command located at the base of your source tree. You need
to do this (very short) step only when you completely remove your source tree for some reason. The only configuration step is to set up where
various binaries—including system executable and your kernel—will be created when you run
later steps. Run
configure --help to find out more including available command line options.
Note that by default OS/161 installs things to the root directory
$HOME/os161/root, which is a fine plan to put things if you are working on a shared machine. For our dedicated VM we use
$HOME/root to shorten the directory paths a bit, but this requires that you use the
--ostree argument to
configure. If you forget
this argument either now or when you need to rerun
configure later, you will install things into
This has caused confusion for some students previously, so please be
3.3. Configure Your OS/161 Kernel
The kernel sources for OS/161 are in the
kern subdirectory, which has its own configuration script. Change into
kern/conf and look around. You should notice a configuration script, a base configuration file (
conf.kern), and four configurations that include
You should take a look at
conf.kern and one of the configurations to get a sense of the format. But for now, the only thing we’re
concerned about is ensuring that we enable
dumbvm for this assignment. You’re going to write a full-fledged virtual memory
(VM) system in ASST3, but for the first few assignments
dumbvm provides enough of a
"dumb" VM to allow you to proceed. Configure a kernel now with
The OS/161 kernel configuration process sets various options that control how your kernel gets built, so unlike the configuration step above you
will probably need to modify these files at some point during later assignments. In particular,
conf.kern determines what source
files get included in your kernel build, so if you add sources to the kernel you’ll need to add them to
conf.kern as well.
3.4. Build Your OS/161 Kernel
Once you’re successfully configured your OS/161 kernel you should have a directory to compile in, as well as a reminder about a build step that you might forget. Once you change into that directory you are ready to build a kernel!
One important note before you start. You are probably used to using
make to build software on UNIX-like systems.
However, the OS/161 sources use
make, which has a different
Makefile syntax 3.
To avoid confusion, BSD
make has been installed on your system as
bmake. So while you might normally run
make clean to reset your build and remove all of the build targets, when working with OS/161 you would run
There are three steps:
Building the dependencies (
bmake depend). This scans all of the source files that you have configured to be part of your kernel and ensures that all their header files are also included.
Building the kernel (
bmake). This generates your kernel binary.
Installing the kernel (
bmake install). This installs your kernel into the root directory that you configured above.
Run these three commands now and check that they complete successfully. Then change into your root directory and look around. You should see a fresh kernel. If you don’t, review the steps above until your kernel builds successfully.
Now that you have a kernel, the next step is to run it. But how? Given that your kernel doesn’t yet have any useful features, it would be impossible to run it on real hardware, or even in a fully-featured VM like VirtualBox.
Instead, OS/161 kernels are built to be run by a special-purpose system simulator called
sys161, or System/161. Compared to other
VMs or full-system simulators,
sys161 is simpler and faster but retains enough realism to enable OS/161 kernel development. Apart
from floating point support and certain issues relating to RAM cache management, it provides an accurate emulation of a MIPS processor
Unlike OS/161, we do not expect you to modify
sys161. However, you do need to configure the simulated machine that
sys161 provides by choosing the number of simulated CPU cores, the amount of simulated memory, and the number of simulated disk
drives. Here is a
sys161.conf file that you can use to get started. You should read and understand the structure of this configuration file so that you can modify
it as needed in later assignments.
3.6. Running Your First Kernel
Now that you have a kernel and a
sys161 configuration file you should be ready to go. Fire up your kernel and see what happens. Poke
around a bit at the menu. Run a test or two. And then shut down.
What just happened? You ran one computer program (
sys161) that loaded your kernel (from the
kernel) file. Your kernel
is itself a program expressed as a series of MIPS r3000 instructions, which were interpreted by
sys161 and simulated as if they
had executed on real hardware. Of course, this includes the ability read from and write to a console device, allowing you to interact with your
Examine the output produced by your kernel as it boots and shuts down. You should be able to answer the following questions:
Which version of System/161 and OS/161 are you using?
Where was OS/161 developed and copyrighted?
How much memory and how many CPU cores was System/161 configured to use?
What configuration was used by your running kernel?
How many times has your kernel been compiled?
Before going on try the following exercises:
Boot your OS/161 kernel with 8 cores.
Try booting with 256K of memory. What happens?
Configure System/161 to use a fixed value to initialize its random number generator. (This can be helpful when debugging non-deterministic kernel behavior.)
3.7. Kernel Development Workflow
As you saw above, building an OS/161 kernel from scratch involves five steps:
Configuring the entire OS/161 source tree by running
configurein the root of the source directory
Configuring the kernel by running
Building the dependencies by running
bmake dependin the compilation subdirectory
Building the kernel by running
Installing the kernel by running
The first step only needs to be done when you download a new OS/161 source tree. The second step only needs to be done when you start a new assignment
or add files to your kernel build by editing
kern/conf/conf.kern. Rebuilding the dependencies in step three is also not usually
necessary unless you have reconfigured your kernel.
So that leaves the last two (
bmake ; bmake install) as your normal kernel development workflow. Note that
bmake is usually
smart enough to detect what you changed and not recompile things unnecessarily, but if you think that it hasn’t accomplished that correctly
you can always run a
bmake clean to force it to start over.
However, if things aren’t building properly you may want to rerun the kernel configuration and dependencies steps just to be sure. Step 1 is almost never necessary to repeat unless you’ve completely started over and removed your entire previous OS/161 source tree.
3.8. Building the User Space Tools
If you change into your root directory you should see only a few files, including your compiled kernel, a symbolic link pointing to that kernel,
sys161.conf file that configures
sys161. That’s fine for now, and all your need until ASST2.
But your OS/161 kernel would not be very interesting or useful if it couldn’t run user programs. So let’s build those now. Head over
to the base of your source directory and run
bmake followed by
bmake install. This generates a lot of output, but when
it’s done return to your root directory. You should see a directory structure including
containing cross-compiled user binaries that your OS/161 kernel will eventually be able to run.
Note that building the user space tools is not part of the kernel development cycle. Unless you modify or add tests in the
userland subdirectory of your source directory—which you are encouraged to do—you should not need to rebuild or reinstall
these binaries. And until you begin
ASST2 your kernel can’t run user binaries anyway, so this part of the build process is completely
useless. We only point this out because compiling and installing the user space tools takes enough time to be annoying, so don’t let it
slow you down unnecessarily. Focus your development loop on your kernel.
4. Exploring OS/161
One of the core challenges of the
ops-class.org assignments is working with OS/161, a large, complicated, and unfamiliar code base.
OS/161 contains roughly 40K non-commenting lines of code and 25K comments spread across 570 C, header, and assembly files. Reading and understanding all of that code would take much more time than you want to spend. And of course you are going to make things worse, since your solutions will add considerably to what is already there 5.
Luckily, OS/161 contains a large amount of code that you never need to understand or change, some amount of code that you need to be familiar but
not intimate with, and a small amount that you must understand in detail. Distinguishing between these categories is critical to your success.
For example, the
loadelf source code each fall into one of these three categories.
See if you can decide which is which, or return to this question after you work on some of the questions below.
To become familiar with a code base, there is no substitute for actually poking around. Browse through the tree a bit to get a sense of how things are structured. Glance through some source code for files that look interesting. OS/161 is also very well commented, as befits a pedagogical code base.
Most of the OS/161 sources are C source (
.c) and header (
.h) files. Your kernel does also contain a bit of assembly code
.S) files. You will not need to understand or modify the assembly code, but it does contain some fairly interesting pieces of code
executed during boot and during context switches. So you may want to take a look at it at some point. The assembly code is also extremely well commented 6.
You should use the code reading questions below to guide an initial exploration of the OS/161 sources. While the questions won’t require you
look at every line of code or even every file, we strongly recommend that you at least glance at all the kernel sources in the
Some parts of the code may seem confusing since we have not discussed how any OS/161 subsystems work. However, it is still useful to review the code now and get a high-level idea of what is happening in each subsystem. If you do not understand the low-level details now, that is fine.
4.1. The Top of the Source Directory
Your OS/161 source directory contains the following files:
CHANGES: describes the evolution of OS/161 and changes in previous versions.
configure: the top-level configuration script that you ran previously.
Makefile: the top-level
Makefileused to build the user space binaries.
The source directory contains the following subdirectories:
common/: code used both by the kernel and user programs, mostly standard C library functions.
design/: contains design documents describing several OS/161 components.
kern/: the kernel source code, and the subdirectory where you will spend most of your time.
man/: the OS/161 man pages appear here. The man pages document (or specify) every program, every function in the C library, and every system call. You will use the system call man pages for reference in the course of ASST2. The man pages are HTML and can be read with any browser.
mk/: fragments of
Makefilesused to build the system.
userland/: user space libraries and program code.
If you have previously configured and built in this directory there are also some additional files and directories that have been created, such
4.2. User Land
userland/ source subdirectory, you will find:
bin/: all the utilities that are typically found in
ls, etc. Programs in
/bin/are considered fundamental utilities that the system needs to run.
include/: these are the include files that you would typically find in
/usr/include(in our case, a subset of them). These are user include files, not kernel include files.
lib/: library code lives here. We have only two libraries:
libc, the C standard library, and
hostcompat, which is for recompiling OS/161 programs for the host UNIX system. There is also a
crt0directory, which contains the startup code for user programs.
sbin/: this is the source code for the utilities typically found in
/sbinon a typical UNIX installation. In our case, there are some utilities that let you halt the machine, power it off, and reboot it, among other things.
testbin/: these are pieces of test code that we will use to test and grade your assignments.
You don’t need to understand the files in
but you certainly will later on. Eventually, you will want to modify these or write your own utilities and these are good models. Similarly,
you need not read and understand everything in
userland/include but you should know enough about what’s there to be able to get around the
source tree easily. The rest of our code walk-through is going to focus on
4.3. Kernel Sources
Now let’s navigate to the
kern/ source subdirectory. Once again, there is a
Makefile installs header files but does not build anything. In addition, we have more subdirectories
for each component of the kernel as well as some utility directories and configuration files.
This is where architecture-specific code goes. By architecture-specific, we mean the code that differs depending on the hardware platform on
which you’re running. There are two directories here:
mips which contains code specific to the MIPS processor and
sys161 which contains code specific to the System/161 simulator.
kern/arch/mips/conf/conf.arch: this file tells the kernel configuration script where to find the machine-specific, low-level functions it needs (throughout
kern/arch/mips/include/: this folder and its subdirectories include files for the machine-specific constants and functions.
kern/arch/mips/: The other directories contain source files for the machine-dependent code that the kernel needs to run. Most of this code is quite low-level.
kern/arch/sys161/conf/conf.arch: Similar to
kern/arch/sys161/include:These files are include files for the System/161-specific hardware, constants, and functions.
This is where you build kernels. In the compile directory, you will find one subdirectory for each kernel configuration target you have used
you want to build. For example, if you configure your kernel with the
DUMBVM configuration to turn on
DUMBVM subdirectory will be created in
kern/compile where you can compile your
dumbvm kernel. This directory and build organization is typical of UNIX installations
and is not universal across all operating systems.
kern/conf/config: is the script that takes a configuration file, like
GENERIC, and creates the corresponding build directory.
This directory contains kernel tests that evaluate multiple parts of your system. Some of these will work right away (
sy1), others will not (
sy3), and others you will have to write (
sy5). You are more
than welcome—encouraged even—to add your own kernel tests. However, please note that during automated tests we
will replace the contents of this directory to ensure that your kernel runs the right tests.
This is where all the low level device management code is stored. Unless you are really interested, you can safely ignore most of this directory.
These are the include files that the kernel needs. The
kern subdirectory contains include files that are visible not only to the
operating system itself, but also to user programs. Consider why it’s named
"kern" and where the files end up when installed.
This is where the kernel is initialized and where the kernel main function and menu are implemented.
This directory contains the code implementing the thread abstraction and synchronization primitives.
This is the directory that contains the starter code that you will need to complete ASST1.
This is where you will add code to create and manage user level processes. As it stands now, OS/161 runs only kernel threads—there is no support for user level code. (Try running the shell from the OS/161 menu and see what happens.) In ASST2, you’ll implement this support.
This directory is also fairly vacant. In ASST3, you’ll implement virtual memory and most of your code will go in here.
The file system implementation has two directories which we’ll present in turn.
kern/vfs is the file system independent layer—`vfs` stands for virtual file system. It establishes a framework into which you can add new file systems easily. You will want
to go look at
vnode.h before looking at this directory.
4.4. Source Exploration Exercises
Use your new-found knowledge of the OS/161 source code to answer the questions that follow. You may also find standard UNIX utilities like
grep useful when searching through your OS/161 source code.
What function initializes the kernel during boot, and what subsystems are currently initialized?
What VM system does your kernel use by default? What is wrong with it?
OS/161 ships with two working synchronization primitives. What are they?
How do you create a thread in OS/161? Give some examples of code that currently creates multiple threads.
OS/161 has a system for printing debugging messages to the console. How does it work? How could it be useful?
copyoutdo? What is special about these functions compared to other approaches to copying memory in C, like
What is a zombie thread?
What is the difference between a thread sleeping and a thread yielding?
Explain the difference between machine dependent and machine independent code. Where would you put both in the OS/161 source tree?
What functions are used to enable and restore interrupts? Would this be sufficient to ensure mutual exclusion on an OS/161 kernel?
5. Your OS/161 Toolchain
Successfully developing an OS/161 kernel requires more than just building and running a kernel. You also need to edit source code, share code with others, and debug and test your kernel.
To complete ASST0, we’ll provide an overview and some exercises using the rest of the OS/161 toolchain: in particular, Git and GDB. But let’s start with discussing how to edit OS/161 source code.
5.1. Editing OS/161
While we don’t specifically support any particular editing or code browsing software, we suggest that you use an editor that is designed
for working with source code. Command line tools like
vim work well and, when combined with
tmux, produce a very powerful command-line development environment. Graphical editors like Eclipse or Visual
Studio are also fine but more of a hassle to set up. Decide what works best for you.
When you read and begin to modify source code, you will also want to absorb it’s stylistic conventions. Like any other hacker, David Holland has his preferences about indentation, line width, function signatures, where to put braces, and tabs versus spaces. Adopting these will make it much easier to work on OS/161 and ensure that your changes fit in. This is also a critical skill to learn as you begin to contribute to other shared code bases. At minimum, you and your partner should agree on style so that you don’t drive each other crazy or spend hours reformatting each others' code.
5.2. Collaborating with Git
As described previously, we are not going to go into the use of Git in detail. But we will point out that using Git is not optional for completing
ops-class.org assignments. We distribute our base sources using Git and will use Git to push updates to you. Our testing tool,
submits assignments for testing using Git.
One additional requirement is that you have a private Git repository so that you do not inadvertently share your solutions with others.
test161 submission system will refuse to grade your assignments if it detects that your Git repository is public. Getting your
hands on a private Git repository is not hard. If you are a student,
GitHub will allow you to set up a limited number of private repositories
for instructional use.
GitLab.com provides private Git repositories for free, as
do other sites such as
BitBucket. And your course staff may also set up private
Git repositories for you to use.
If you are completing the
ops-class.org assignments alone, you may wonder whether you need Git. The short answer is yes.
Every programmer, including you, should get in the habit of setting up version control every time you start a project. It’s the first
thing that you should do. Always. Every time. No exceptions. Why? There are a lot of reasons.
5.2.1. Git exercises
If you are just getting started with Git, here are some exercises specific to OS/161 that you may want to try:
Modify your kernel so that it prints out your email address at the right spot during boot. Use Git to show what files have changed. Commit your changes, and confirm that your work tree is now clean. Use Git to show the history of your repository, and to generate a line-by-line breakdown of who is responsible for each of the current lines in the file that prints the menu.
Modify your kernel so that it prints a bad word during boot. Use Git to show what files have changed. Decide that this is bad idea and use Git to back out your change.
Modify your kernel so that it builds but does not boot. (Try adding a null pointer exception somewhere during the boot sequence or in the menu.) Check in your changes and build a kernel. Run your kernel and realize your mistake. Use Git to revert your previous commit containing the mistake. Confirm that your kernel now builds and boots properly.
Repeat the previous exercise but make your changes in a new branch. When you realize your mistake, return to your master branch and show that you can still build and boot. At that point abandon and delete the new branch you created.
Set up a private remote repository so that you and your partner can share changes. Configure your repository so that it pushes and pulls your master branch to your new repository by default. Pick a file to edit jointly, something long enough so that you both can add changes. Add a comment to the top of the file. Have your partner add a comment to the bottom of the file. Use Git to merge your changes through the remote repository.
Pick another file to edit jointly, but this time create a conflict by both adding different comments to the same line of the file. Using Git, confirm that the edits create a merge conflict. Use Git to handle the conflict and complete the merge. Try doing this twice and see if you can force each partner to handle the merge conflict.
5.3. Debugging Using GDB
GDB—or the GNU debugger—is another extremely well-documented tool which we will let you learn on your own. Unlike
Git, GDB is not required to complete the
ops-class.org assignments. But that’s like saying that shoes aren’t required
to climb Mt. Everest. You can make it without GDB, through good old
printf debugging and pure deductive reasoning. But it will be very, very painful. You will be much happier if you learn to use GDB.
The only complication to using GDB to debug your OS/161 kernel is that the machine simulator
sys161 gets in the way. As a result,
the way that you hook up the debugger to your running kernel is a bit different than you might be used to if you have used GDB previously. For
example, if you try this in your root directory:
os161-gdb sys161 kernel
you will end up debugging
sys161, not your kernel, which is not what you want. And if you run
nothing will happen at all because you haven’t started the
sys161 simulator required to run your kernel.
Instead, you need to start the simulator and the debugger separately. However, it is critical that they run in the same directory. A terminal multiplexer
tmux comes in handy here. Here’s what to do:
In one terminal, change to your root directory and start your kernel. There is a special option to
sys161that will cause it to wait for a connection from the debugger before booting. Use that to make sure that you can establish the connection before boot.
In a second terminal, change to your root directory and start the debugger by running
Unfortunately, you are not quite done. You may have noticed that the kernel is still waiting for a debugger connection. To establish that connection, type the following at the GDB prompt:
target remote unix:.sockets/gdb
At this point GDB should confirm that it is connected to the
sys161 simulator and you can proceed. Note that the kernel is stopped
at this point as if you have set up a breakpoint, so you need to instruct it to continue.
Happily, new versions of
sys161 will wait explicitly at shutdown for a debugger connection if something goes wrong. Try booting your
kernel and running the
panic command to observe this behavior. This gives you a chance to connect a debugger and poke around in
cases where your kernel panics and you weren’t expecting it. That said, we suggest that you always run your
kernel with the debugger attached from boot.
If you get tired of typing these commands, there are ways to set up a GDB alias for the
target command and have it be run when GDB
starts. For the even more adventurous, you can set up a
tmux script that will automatically create two windows, boot your kernel
in one and start the debugger in the other. Programming FTW!
Finally, note that because GDB is debugging your kernel through the
sys161 system simulator, not all GDB features are supported. Watchpoints,
for example, are known not to work. In addition, when stepping through code you should keep in mind that your kernel is multithreaded and that
other threads may have run in-between each step.
5.3.1. GDB exercises
If you are just getting started with GDB, here are some exercises specific to OS/161 that you may want to try:
Set a breakpoint on the
panicfunction. Initiate a panic from the kernel menu and confirm that GDB hits the break point. Inspect the call stack and step up and down a few times before allowing the kernel to continue and
Create a panic by modifying your OS/161 source code. Use GDB to find the source of the panic. If you are working with a partner, have your partner hide a panic in the source code and use GDB to find it. Then hide one for them.
Step through kernel boot, stepping in to and over a few of the boot helper functions that initialize various subsystems.
Put a breakpoint on the kernel exception handler and step through it when it fires. Use it to determine what generates exceptions when your kernel is sitting idly at the menu.